The 5 Best Litter Box Liners With Holes | Detailed Review

A litter bin with a liner
The best litter box liners with holes are the Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners.

Are you a cat owner? If so, you might be looking for the best sifting litter box liners.

Choosing the best litter box liners with holes can be very difficult.

There are hundreds of options on the market today and they all claim to be the best.

Cat litter liners with holes that allow for easier cleaning and less litter tracking are what I like to call a “litter box game-changer”.

Have you ever used a litter box liner, the kind with holes in it?

I’ve searched high and low for the best sifting litter liners on the market and boy are there so many options out there these days.

It can be hard to tell which ones are good or bad. Not all choices are created equal, and some liners seem less than ideal.

I’ve tried several types along with the plain old plastic lining before settling on the one that is perfect for my cats.

A lot of people use it because it helps keep the litter box clean, and odor-free and saves money in the long run.

So if you are in the market for some new sifting cat litter liners for your cat’s litter box and want to save some money along the way, then keep on reading!

The Best Litter Box Liner with Holes Top Picks

If you are pressed for time, here are the top 5 picks of sifting litter box liners that I recommend for your cat’s litter box:

  1. Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners, X-Giant
  2. Imperial Cat Neat ‘N Litter Sifting Liner, 28 count
  3. Alfapet Kitty Cat Pan Disposable, Sifting Liners
  4. SpeedySift Litter Box Sifting Liners
  5. Fresh Step Drawstring Cat Litter Box Liners

What are sifting litter box liners?

Sifting litter box liners are liners with holes in them that allow you to sift the waste out of the liner.

They allow you to scoop only the waste and replace it with clean litter instead of dumping out the entire contents of the litter box.

One of the main reasons cat owners use sifting litter box liners is because they do a better job of keeping litter from sticking to the bottom of the pan.

Another reason is that they make cleaning your cat’s litter box much easier.

By separating and removing waste, you eliminate the need to scoop out clumps and remove stuck-on waste.

Sifting liners are designed to fit over a specific sifting litter box, so you’ll need to pay attention to which type of liner you’re buying.

Some sifting liners have an elastic band at the top that helps them stay in place, while others have a drawstring closure or a grommeted hole for hanging on hooks.

The Best Litter Box Sifting Liners

1.     Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners, X-Giant

Sifting Cat Pan Liners by Van Ness makes cleaning your cat’s litter box a breeze.

This sifting kitty litter liner fits pans up to 22 x 18 inches in size.


  • It’s environmentally friendly as it’s made entirely of 100% recycled plastic.
  • Uses no-tear 3-ply technology that can withstand daily use.
  • A rubber band is included to keep the liners in place.
  • It saves on cleaning time since it eliminates the need to clean your cat’s litter pan every time you change her litter.


  1. Can be quite messy upon use.
  2. An aggressive cat may rip through them

2.     Imperial Cat Neat ‘N Litter Sifting Liner, 28 count

28 sifting liners and two solid liners are included in this pack, which is meant to fit regular boxes and hooded pans.

The rubber band holds the liners in place.


  • Keeps the litter box fresh and tidy.
  • Sifting increases the life of your clay or clumping litter by up to 50%, resulting in less waste.
  • These cat litter bags with holes fit most regular boxes and hooded pans and work with practically all clay and clumping litters.


  • They require you to hold them in place using a rubber band as they aren’t elasticized.
  • The holes may be large and poop falls through them creating a mess.

3.     Alfapet Kitty Cat Pan Disposable, Sifting Liners

By sifting the sand and discarding the bag, these sifting bags let you get rid of the kitty litter while keeping the cat pan clean and mess-free.


  • Makes the life of pet owners easier when it comes to cleaning the cat litter box.
  • Each box of disposable sifting liners includes a durable rubber band to assist hold the liner in place.
  • These cat litter bags with holes are a multi-size fit for various cat pans.
  • They provide quick sifting action, allowing you to do the job faster, cleaner, and without scooping.
  • Comes with a money-back guarantee.


  • The rubber band may be stretchy and not hold the bags firmly in place.
  • Not ideal for clawing cats.

4.     SpeedySift Litter Box Sifting Liners

Comes in 14 sifting liners and one bottom no hole liner in each set.


  • Prevents urine from leaking out and litter from falling to the bottom of the bin when two of them are offset and stacked together.
  • Works well with non-lightweight clumping clay litter.
  • Good odor control mechanism.


  • Clawing cats will damage the top liners.
  • Doesn’t work well with large pellet litter.

5.     Fresh Step Drawstring Cat Litter Box Liners

Litter box liners include a drawstring design that allows for quick and easy cleanup.

Pull the drawstrings on both sides of the kitty box liner and tie the cords together to secure the contents.

Each box has seven kitty litter bags.


  • They are thick litter box liners that are difficult for your cat to rip through.
  • Kitty litter will stay in your litter box liners and off your flooring if you use high-quality cat litter bags.
  • The drawstring design allows for quick and easy cleanup.
  • These Fresh Step giant litter box liners are designed to fit most big litter pans.
  • Compatible with a variety of kitty litter boxes; use with your favorite litter pan.


  • Not as scratch-resistant.
  • Are not self-elasticized
A cat yawning

Factors to Consider When Buying Sifting Liners for Litter Box

  1. Choose a quality litter box liner that can withstand scratching and tearing in case you have a ferocious digger for a cat.
  2. Go for one that fits perfectly into the cat’s litter box. If it’s too large, it creates folds in the liner which are a target for scratching by your cat, and urine can seep through, accumulate below and emit serious odors. If it is too small a fit for your litter box, it is easier to tear should your cat scratch it.
  3. Ensure you add enough fresh clean litter on top of the cat box liner so that there’s enough depth to avoid easy ripping of the liner when the cat digs.

How To Make DIY sifting litter liners

What you’ll need:

  1. One large plastic bag (I used a laundry detergent bag)
  2. Rubber band
  3. Two bins (one for scooping out the waste and another for sifting out the dirty litter.)


  1. To make custom sifting litter liners for your cat’s litter box, fold down one side of a large plastic trash bag with holes in it.
  2. Insert this end into a rectangular or square plastic storage bin with high sides.
  3. Secure with a rubber band at the top for extra protection against spills and odors
  4. Add your cat litter and it’s ready for use.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Do cats like litter box liners and what should you be aware of?

Some cats do not respond well to a litter box with a liner and they may end up abandoning the box and using a different spot for elimination.

Should the urine accumulate in the gathers and corner folds, the odor from the litter box can be appalling.

Cats that are diggers can sink their sharp claws as they dig to the bottom of the litter box. This will result in tears and a damaged liner that allows the urine to seep through and accumulate at the bottom of the litter box. This will result in nasty odors.

This reality of smells will hit your nostrils when you lift the plastic liner to dispose of it because soiled litter and stale urine will be falling out of the tears into the bottom of the box.

If this is your situation, take my advice and ditch the litter box liners with holes.

Should I use a liner in my cat’s litter box?

In case you are wondering what the purpose of a litter box liner is, there are many reasons why you should use one:

  • First, it greatly reduces the amount of dust and odor that comes from your cat’s litter box. The liners are made to contain urine and feces as well as absorb the odor. If you were to not use a liner and just scoop the clumps out of the litter box, it would be very messy and you would not be able to contain the smell as much.
  • Second, it makes cleaning up after your cat much easier. You can just pull up the liner and throw everything away with no mess left behind in the litter box.
  • Third, it saves money because you don’t have to clean out your litter box every time. You can just replace the liner and put in a new litter instead of pouring out all of the old litter.
  • Liners can save you time and make cleaning your cat’s litter box easier. They also may reduce the mess your cat leaves behind when it buries its waste.

How do litter box liners work?

Sifting litter box liners have a special design that separates the waste from the clean litter.

These liners are designed with slotted holes to allow the waste to pass through, but also large enough to prevent litter from passing through.

Instead of having to scoop out clumps of used litter, you can simply lift the lid off your sifting litter pan, grab the handles on the liner and drag it out.

The holes in the bottom of the pan will allow clean litter to fall through while containing the used litter in the bag.

When you use sifting litter boxes, you don’t have to do any scooping at all.

What can I use instead of a litter liner?

  • You can make your liners by cutting a plastic garbage bag into a circle and placing it in the litter box.
  • You can also use a newspaper as an alternative. It’s biodegradable and disposable. Using newspaper to line the bottom of the box doesn’t work perfectly, because it doesn’t absorb odor and it’s easy for a cat to knock out of place.
  • Use regular trash bags.
  • Plastic bags also work well as liners.
PS: Plastic grocery bags are not made to withstand the weight of the litter and waste, and they may rip and spill.
  • Some people use paper towels, but that costs more than liners.

Cleaning the box will be a bit more labor-intensive with either of these options, but they’re cheap and effective.

Are litter box liners safe?

Litter box liners can be safe and convenient, but they do have some disadvantages.

Some people believe that using a litter box liner can be harmful to cats.

The idea is that some cats may eat pieces of plastic liners, which can cause intestinal blockage. This is true, and it’s something cat owners should be aware of.

However, as long as you’re buying the right type of liner and removing it properly every time you change your cat’s litter, there’s no need to worry.

If you’re concerned about your cat getting sick from eating pieces of plastic bag or liner, stick to using products that are specifically made for use in litter boxes.

Commercial liners are typically made out of a low-density polyethylene material that isn’t harmful if swallowed.

They’re also thicker than regular bags, which makes them less likely to tear and spill litter all over the floor during removal.

It’s also important to properly remove the old liner when changing your kitty’s litter.

If the liner tears or breaks while you’re pulling it out of the box, be sure to check for any leftover pieces that might have fallen into the new litter before letting your cat use the box again.


The box liners with holes are convenient to use.

They also keep our cat from tracking litter out of the box when she scratches around in it.

Besides, it makes cleaning up the box very easy.

It will cut down on the smell, which will cut down on the work you need to do when cleaning out your litter box.

But remember, it’s important to keep your cat’s litter box clean.

No matter what kind of liners you decide to purchase, consistent maintenance is the most important step in keeping your home (and your cat) healthy and happy.

In the end, I hope that this article will help you make an informed decision about which kind of litter box liner you want to go with.

That said, I do recommend the Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners to those of you who want an easy-to-clean option for your litter box.

It saves time and effort, and it helps you keep your litter box area in tip-top shape.

I have to admit, I feel like my cat is pampered too much.

But she’s also a pretty awesome kitty and I need her content.

We have a great relationship between us, else she’d be on top of the couch instead of me.

Still, if I can think of anything better than this for her to do, please let me know. She seems to enjoy it.